What Should I Actually Build? (Two Very Different Answers)
Generic advice hands you a catalog. A real answer tells you where the money is already sitting in what you've built
Ask an AI what digital products you could sell and it’ll hand you a list: ebooks, templates, courses, presets, printables. A complete catalog. Technically correct, completely useless.
You don’t have a product-category problem. You have a packaging problem.
Here’s what the generic answer can’t tell you: you’ve already done the hard part. You built a curriculum people trust. That’s not nothing. That’s actually the whole thing. The question isn’t what category of product to add. It’s how to pull two distinct products out of what’s already there.
The free readers who follow your work but won’t commit to a cohort? They want the methodology itself, portable and self-directed, something they can run on their own. A standalone toolkit built from your framework sells to exactly that person. They’ve been reading you for months. They believe in the system. They just don’t want the cohort experience.
The readers who want guidance, who’d pay more for access to you inside the work? That’s a done-with-you intensive, the kind of high-ticket offer that doesn’t lead with a price tag. Same source material, different container, different price point, different buyer.
Two products. Both built from what you already have. Neither requires inventing anything new.
That’s the gap between a list and an answer. A list tells you what kinds of things exist. An answer tells you where the money is sitting in your specific business, right now, without building from scratch.
A catalog of ideas is noise dressed up as strategy. An answer that knows your site skips the noise entirely.
Worth knowing
How do I know which of my free readers would buy a standalone toolkit versus a done-with-you intensive?
The signal is usually in how they engage with your free content. Readers who consume and self-apply are toolkit buyers. Readers who reply, ask follow-up questions, or want feedback are intensive buyers. Your list behavior tells you more than any survey will.
Does packaging my methodology as a standalone product risk undermining the cohort?
Only if they're priced and positioned identically. A self-directed toolkit and a guided intensive serve different needs at different moments. Done right, the toolkit often becomes the entry point that makes the cohort feel like the obvious next step.
Your next course is a conversation away.
MemberPress.ai drafts real MemberPress courses, lessons, and quizzes in the exact shape the plugin needs — on your own WordPress site, as drafts in your editor. Tell Opal once. She handles the rest.
Connect your site→