MemberPress vs. WishList Member: Where Each One Actually Wins
Both are WordPress membership plugins with tiered pricing. Here's where they genuinely differ: transaction fees and what's bundled at each tier.
Both MemberPress and WishList Member solve the same base problem: turn a WordPress site into a membership business. The differences show up in the pricing model and what’s bundled at each tier, not in whether either one “works.”
The entry price isn’t the real comparison
WishList Member’s current plans start at $149.50/year (Basic), stepping up to $249.50/year (Plus) and $349.50/year (Pro). The difference between tiers is mostly site count (1, 2, and 5 sites) and which of its 30+ integrations unlock, plus perks like team accounts and unlimited CourseCure quizzes at the top tier.
MemberPress’s tiers (Launch, Growth, Scale) run a similar shape, but the real differentiator isn’t the sticker price — it’s a transaction fee. Launch charges 4.9% per payment; Growth and Scale drop that to 0%. On a plugin whose whole job is helping you get paid, that fee structure matters more than the label price once you’re actually processing revenue.
What’s bundled changes the calculus
WishList Member’s tiers gate integrations and site count. MemberPress’s tiers gate a wider product footprint: Growth adds ClubSuite (forums, member directory, messaging) and CoachKit (coaching tools); Scale adds Easy Affiliate (its own affiliate platform, normally a $499/yr product on its own) and a REST API for custom automation.
If your membership is content-and-drip only, that extra footprint may be dead weight — WishList Member’s simpler, integration-focused tiers can be the leaner fit, and its lower entry price is real for a single-site operator who doesn’t need any of it.
If you’re building toward community, coaching, or an affiliate program as part of the membership itself, MemberPress’s higher tiers fold tools you’d otherwise buy and integrate separately into one price.
The actual question
Don’t compare list prices. Compare what you’d actually need to buy alongside the cheaper option to match what the pricier one already includes — and whether a transaction fee on every payment costs more, over a year, than the tier price difference.
That’s the same principle behind everything we build MemberPress.ai to do: not a generic verdict, but the one that fits your specific business. It learns about your site and gives you targeted tactics for where your setup — and your pricing — should actually sit.
Worth knowing
Is WishList Member cheaper than MemberPress?
Its list price starts lower, but MemberPress's Launch tier carries a 4.9% transaction fee that WishList Member's plans don't have an equivalent of, and MemberPress's higher tiers bundle tools (coaching, communities, an affiliate platform) that would otherwise need separate integrations. The real cost comparison depends on what you're actually using.
Which one has better integrations?
WishList Member's higher tiers unlock more third-party integrations (30+ at its top tier). MemberPress takes a different approach at its higher tiers: instead of just connecting to more outside tools, it bundles equivalent functionality (community, coaching, affiliate management) directly into the product.
Do I need the most expensive tier of either platform?
Only if you're using what it unlocks. A single-site, drip-content-only membership doesn't need WishList Member's Pro tier or MemberPress's Scale tier — check the feature list against what your business actually does before paying for headroom you won't use.
Get your membership to its first paying member.
Connect your site and tell Opal what you sell. She sets up your Join and Checkout pages and tells you what’s left before anyone can pay, like connecting your own Stripe or PayPal. Your password never leaves your site.
Connect your site→